Location: Home > History > General > The Suspicions of Mr Whicher: Or the Murder at Road Hill House

The Suspicions of Mr Whicher: Or the Murder at Road Hill House

Author: Kate Summerscale
Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Category: Book

Buy New: Ł45.00

New (2) Used (3) Collectible (2) from Ł36.68

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

15 reviews
Sales Rank: 13624

Media: Hardcover
Pages: 384
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1.3
Dimensions (in): 8.3 x 5.7 x 1.5

ISBN: 0747582157
EAN: 9780747582151
ASIN: 0747582157

Publication Date: April 7, 2008
Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days
Condition: FIRST EDITION, signed by the author. Perfect condition, dust wrapped cover. Highly collectable investment.

Customer Reviews:

Showing reviews 6-10 of 15

« PREV

1 2 3

I would've enjoyed it more but... June 5, 2008
6 out of 6 found this review helpful

A disturbing crime, the death of a child, treated so coldly and written so much like fiction that after a while you forget that this actually happened and then feel horrified at yourself.
I bought this book based on the intriguing review in the Daily Mail-I know!!!-and would've appreciated it more I think had I not read another review, which without warning gave the murderer away halfway through the article.
Thanks Waterstones magazine.
I was really enjoying reading about the start of detecting in Britain and the influence that Jack Whicher had on people such as Dickens and Wilkie Collins.
It was hard to pick up the book after that.
The writer carefully straddles the difficult areas of making fact interesting enough to read about whilst telling the tale accurately and it is quite horrifying reading how they treated this poor boy's body let alone as a CSI generation how they treated the evidence you want to yell out 'you're contaminating the crime scene!' all the time.
It is very interesting in a then and now way, how much credence was placed on gossip and hearsay and how intuition was so viatl to catching criminals in this forensic modern society we live in where we are scared to tell people details in case they are literally used against us.
It is a fascinating insight into a horrendous crime and a well written intriguing book which I enjoyed very much.

4 out of 5 stars

Just the facts, ma'am May 23, 2008
4 out of 4 found this review helpful

I was slightly disappointed. The author did a fantastic job piecing together the wealth of information about the case -- newspaper reports, official records, letters, interview notes, etc. We know what everyone did in great detail. The author was careful to stick to the facts. She didn't fictionalize or make assumptions. That's good reporting. However, the result was that I was unable to connect with or feel sympathy for any of the people involved, even poor little Savile. All I had was facts, and facts can't put flesh on these people.

It's a good read, but it felt like something was missing. It's not the author's fault though. Unlike today's true crime writers, she didn't have the benefit of personal observation of the players. They just never came to life for me.

5 out of 5 stars

Middle class murder May 5, 2008
7 out of 8 found this review helpful

This absorbing book is an examination of one of the most famous murder cases of the 19th century. Three year old Saville Kent was found horribly murdered in the outdoor privy of Road Hill House in June 1860. Jonathan Whicher, one of the first plain clothes detectives at Scotland Yard, is sent down two weeks after the murder, to help the local police. Whicher becomes convinced that one of the family is responsible for Saville's death. The case exposed the Kents to intrusive publicity, and the family's history was laid bare. Samuel Kent's first wife had died, some said of madness, some said because he was having an affair with the governess. When Samuel then married the governess, and started a second family, the older children were said to feel neglected and jealous. Saville was the favoured child of this second marriage. Had one of his half-siblings murdered him out of spite & jealousy? Had Saville seen his father in bed with the nursemaid and been killed to keep him quiet? Had a jealous neighbour or disgruntled former servant taken their revenge on Samuel by murdering his beloved child? All these theories were canvassed in the press, and Jonathan Whicher's investigation reached an inconclusive end. His career was damaged by his failure to bring the culprit to trial, although he was confident he knew who the murderer was. Five years later, the murderer was brought to trial after a dramatic confession. But was this the truth? Summerscale's recreation of the crime is masterly. She shows the influence of the murder on the sensation fiction of Wilkie Collins and Mary Elizabeth Braddon which was so popular in the 1860s. The case exposed middle-class society's secrets and flaws.

5 out of 5 stars

Brilliantly researched and completely engrossing May 1, 2008
22 out of 23 found this review helpful

The murder of a young child which took place at Road Hill House, Wiltshire in 1860 captured the imagination of the public and turned everyone into amateur detectives. The perfect example of a country house murder with a finite amount of suspects also inspired writers of the time such as Dickens, Wilkie Collins and Mary Elizabeth Braddon.

'The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher' is structured so that first, we learn the details of the crime, then we learn about the investigation which leads on to what happened next and the author's own theory based on the evidence. To say this book is well-researched in something of an understatement; if someone goes through a toll road, we know how much they pay; if someone moves to London we find out who they lived next door to; if someone left a will, we find out exactly what they left and to whom. I'm sure this level of detail would be irritating to some, but I found it absolutely incredible!

The book is also interesting in giving us a taste of the time, the attitudes of the people, the ways in which the Police force was growing and how events were shaping literature.

This is an extraordinary achievement and engrossing throughout. I can't wait to see what she will come up with next!

4 out of 5 stars

Murder most horrid April 28, 2008
2 out of 2 found this review helpful

A really engrossing country house murder told with all the suspense and horror that the nation felt on reading the accounts in the press. Summerscale weaves the developments in detection, and how the social scandals of the time were influencing and shaping the definition of the novel itself.
Unlike other reviewers, and having never experienced lsd (pounds, shillings and pence btw), I was amazed at just how many pennies were in a pound and what a shilling could buy!

It isn't perfect: for example there is a theory left to the very end which never gets a proper consideration in the rest of the text.
Also I wonder whilst highlighting the social realities of the time, that some discussion about the huge social restraint placed on women, both the lady of the house and the maid, might have added extra depth.

Still highly recommended.